Bullies fear they’ll be ignored

Now this is an interesting turn of events.

Dr. Craig Orr, who has made a career out of being a scientific gun-for-hire and media go-to guy for negative quotes about salmon farming, is complaining that the new Integrated Management of Aquaculture Plan advisory committee just isn’t fair.

Orr is quoted as saying he thinks environmental groups should have more than three seats at the table, otherwise they will just be “shouted down.”

“All we’re saying is, make it fair,” he said. “Have some (federal fisheries) scientists, have some academics, have some NGO scientists.”

But that’s exactly what the committee has, Dr. Orr. how is it not fair?

The current make-up of the advisory committee already has more environmental group representation than regional districts, yet they are not complaining about fairness. The committee has seven First Nations representations, and seven salmon farm company representatives, which makes perfect sense because it’s all about the Integrated Management of Aquaculture.

How is this not fair? Does Dr. Orr think the First Nations and salmon farm companies should give up some of their seats so environmental groups, who have no direct stake in managing aquaculture, should be given equal footing?

Besides, isn’t it environmental groups who have the tendency to “shout down” anyone who disagrees with them? How did BAMP turn out? How did CAAR’s partnership with Marine Harvest turn out? The ENGOs got mad, took their ball and went home when they found they couldn’t shout and bully the salmon farmers at the table to bend to their will.

These are projects in which Dr. Orr participated. Maybe he doesn’t like to participate in groups where he doesn’t have control over the Talking Stick all of the time.

Or perhaps Orr simply isn’t qualified to sit on the committee, since he’s published more papers about East Coast birds and rabbits than he has about aquaculture in B.C.

Either way, it doesn’t matter because despite his complaining, Orr says he isn’t going to participate.

But Orr said his organization has decided not to participate in the committee. He said he’s been involved in similar processes in the past where “things get blocked.”

“We don’t want to get into an arena where that advice is going to go into a black hole or just give us ulcers,” said Orr.

That’s right. It’s only OK to participate in committees where “things get blocked” for the salmon farmers, and where advice from salmon farmers goes into a “black hole” and where salmon farmers get ulcers.

This response shows that when some salmon farming opponents are denied their bully pulpit, they really aren’t interested in participating and collaborating to help make things better. They just want a platform to berate and condemn the things they hate.

That’s not science, and doesn’t belong at the IMAP advisory committee table.

Advertisements

2 thoughts on “Bullies fear they’ll be ignored”

  1. The governmental scientists that are muzzled will tell you about scientific results, about need for more research in specific areas, and about what science has not been able to do properly because of interference.
    Salmon farms on oceans and in river pathways must be halted. It’s not a big employer, but it does bring a whole lot of money to large foreign investors.
    Doesn’t anyone take science in high school/university anymore?
    At least do this:
    Adhere to the Precautionary Principle.

  2. It reminds me of 2007 when Krkosek published his infamous extinction theory paper at the time that the Pacific Salmon Forum was coming to a much different conclusion about sea lice in the Broughton He published the nonsense then refused to meet with the forum. This is the strategy of the activist. Avoid the science. Go straight to the media with the press release. Hopefully some more clowns like Orr either take their ball and go home or have a “Marlk Lynas moment and realize they have been on an anti science crusade for some time now and just go away and let the rest of us get on with the business of feeding the world responsibly.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s