Efficient use of limited resources

One of the most common criticisms of salmon farming is that it takes several pounds of small wild fish to grow one pound of salmon. This is unsustainable, they say.

This is a valid criticism, but there is a lot of context missing, it’s based on old information, not the current state of salmon farming, and the conclusion is false. It’s like claiming that solar power has less of an environmental impact than wind power, therefore wind power is unsustainable — meanwhile ignoring the fact that most of North America’s electricity comes from burning coal.

Salmon farmers are well aware that there are a finite number of small, wild fish in the sea to use in salmon feed. That’s why for years they have been working to reduce the amount of fishmeal and fish oil in their feed recipes. Salmon farmers are looking at alternative plant and even algae-based protein sources to use in fish feed, which will provide the healthy Omega-3 oils in farmed salmon.

It’s unlikely that salmon farmers will be able to eliminate fishmeal and oil from their feed recipes entirely anytime soon, but the levels are far below what they were just 20 years ago. And even if it was to stay the same as it is now, farmed salmon is without a doubt one of the most efficient uses of resources.

All farm animals have to eat. All farm animals eat feed. And some farm animals use that feed to grow more efficiently than others. They can be compared by their feed conversion ratios — a measurement of how much feed it takes to grow an animal. Feed conversion ratios are expressed as a ratio. For example, it takes 1.2 pounds of feed to grow one pound of farmed salmon.

For a comparison, take a look at this graph:

 

Feed conversion ratios for common livestock

In context, it’s easy to see that farmed salmon is very efficient, even more so than chicken. The only protein source which appears to be more efficient is milk, but the actual protein content in milk is much lower than all other livestock on the graph so you would have to eat an entire tub of yogurt to get the same protein you would get from one three-ounce serving of farmed salmon. And the sugar and fat in an entire tub of yogurt wouldn’t exactly be a health benefit.

For more information about the protein values of other farmed livestock, please read the study on which we based this graph.

Science and the facts about other forms of agriculture shows that it is false to conclude that salmon farming is unsustainable because of feed. Compared to all other forms of livestock farming, nothing is more efficient than salmon farming when it comes to using our planet’s limited resources to grow protein.

Are there concerns? Of course. But in context it’s easy to see that we should be encouraging more salmon farming (and other forms of aquaculture) to feed our planet’s growing population.

It’s an efficient use of our planet’s limited resources, and it’s healthy, too.

Advertisements

4 thoughts on “Efficient use of limited resources”

  1. My question is – what is true wild salmon? Wild natural or wild ranged? I mean is this all wild? Or wild is wild and ranged salmon not wild.

  2. Do you have comparison figures for wild salmon? They eat almost exclusively other small fish and waste a lot of energy in the process. My guess is that, per pound, wild salmon have a much greater impact on global feed fish populations than do farmed fish. And that doesn’t include the environmental impact of fuel, etc., used in catching them.

  3. The comparison to wild fish is a worthwhile contrast to look at as well. The usual figure cited for farmed salmon is 4 kilograms or so of fish meal to make 1 kilogram of fish. But for wild salmon, it’s 4.5 kilograms to make just 0.45 kilograms of fish. The ratio is 4:1 for the farmed salmon versus 10:1 for the wild salmon. Farmed salmon are far more efficient at converting their food into growth.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s